Ajarn.com Ajarn Blogs Jobs Resumes Training Ajarn Street Ajarn Guests Help and Guides


International House - Bangkok
+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 32

Thread: Am I being pedantic here?

  1. #1
    Regular User tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute tropic of cancer has a reputation beyond repute
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    568
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    929

    Am I being pedantic here?

    A young arrogant woman (half-ethiopian, grew up in Brazil) teaches Science on my EP - she used to teach English (on-line tefl).

    Anyhow we have an English camp and she's been put in chrage of one of designing one of the activities. I asked her what she was doing and it was tenses 'game': kids take a 'time' card (now, yesterday etc) and have to form sentences.

    "Like say zey peek 'tomoreow', zey say 'tomoreow I will go to zuh Mall', for insstanz."

    "Actually,' I say, 'in English you wouldn't really say that; unless perhaps it was in response to someone saying 'I don't think you're going to go to the Mall tomorrow.' "

    A somewhat heated argument ensues whereby, she tells me she was a taught be an American ('veyry pro-fession-ale') and proceed to show me a grammar website which allegedly backed her up (of course it did no such thing, not that she was capable of grasping this).She mentioned the use of 'will' in the EP textbook (English Time 4) which she'd used last year. I excavated the book as an indication that even books are capable of clumsy constructions i.e. 'I will plant flowers in the Spring - not so much wrong as a poor introduction to the ways in which 'will' is habitually used. 'The fact is,' I said eventually, 'you're wrong to teach the use of will in the sense you mention. We don't use it that way.'

    Were she not so up herself, I probably wouldn't have got so indignant and tried to pull rank. I know that SL users like 'will' because it's comprehensible and of course getting EP Pratom to say anything is beneficial. Hence I don't really care that she's teaching it.

    Now, not only is she unaware she's essentially wrong, but she's convinced she's right, since English Time is published by the hallowed Oxford University.

    Should I just not have said anything?

  2. #2
    Senior Member Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman has a reputation beyond repute Welshman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Soi Chaiyapruk, Jomtien Beach
    Posts
    4,756
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    1613

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    It's that old chestnut regarding English grammar versus English usage.

    To use 'will' in a sentence is gramatically correct but, as you rightly point out, in common usage it tends to imply emphaticness or determination.

    There's a similar problem with using full verbs instead of contractions...

    for instance

    I'm going to the party tonight - indicates intent or future plan
    I am going to the party tonight - indicates emphaticness and would generally be used by way of a response

    You're not going to the party tonight.
    I am going to the party tonight!

    I quite often get students who tend to revert to the long form of the verb 'I am' 'I will' etc and I've tried explaining the different contexts but I'm not sure it gets through to them.

    In this case I guess, especially as she seems to be pretty pig-headed and closed to arguments, I would give up trying.

  3. #3
    Regular User fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute fencesitter has a reputation beyond repute
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    525
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    Quote Originally Posted by tropic of cancer View Post
    I know that SL users like 'will' because it's comprehensible and of course getting EP Pratom to say anything is beneficial. Hence I don't really care that she's teaching it.
    So then what's your beef? Obviously there is more to this story than you are telling us. Does she have bigger breasts than you?

    By the way, before you go complaining about grammar rules, you ought to learn some yourself. A lot of what you wrote is incomprehensible gibberish....do yourself a favour and stop trying to make yourself out to be a native speaker...clearly you are not...and if you are...Thailand really needs to tighten the regulations...

  4. #4
    Established User martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy has a reputation beyond repute martyboy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    London
    Posts
    456
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    113

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    Probably more acceptable as an answer to the question - "Will you plant flowers in the summer". "No, I will plant flowers in the spring".

    Maybe 'going to' is better as a future intention. Can you really generalize? That's part of the richness of English.

  5. #5
    fending 'em off stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    hunkered in
    Posts
    8,542
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    3462

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    Quote Originally Posted by tropic of cancer View Post
    that even books are capable of clumsy constructions i.e. 'I will plant flowers in the Spring
    dude, in an EFL context youre arguing that THAT is not a grammatical sentence? i cant believe youre raising objection to an "i will" sentence. holy shit.

    not only are you way off base, but are just - well - pedantic and needlessly arrogant. a typical example of a pebble in her eye and boulder in yours.


    Quote Originally Posted by tropic of cancer View Post
    Actually,' I say, 'in English you wouldn't really say that
    Quote Originally Posted by tropic of cancer View Post
    Hence I don't really care that she's teaching it.


    i dont care...but thought id tell her what shes doing is wrong, even if its prefectly normal to teach it. so, i'll fight with my coworker over a nonissue to ensure that i am the one who is regarded as "respected"

    i dont know you, but its pretty clear that her leading the activity bothered you.

  6. #6
    User. Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    2,250
    Blog Entries
    5
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    999

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    I don't think he's off base or arrogant at all. He was just trying to explain to her how we usually speak in English. It sounded to me like he started out trying to be helpful. I don't think it's a big deal, though, especially with kids. They could certainly say "I will go to the mall" to an English speaker and be understood.

  7. #7
    fending 'em off stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    hunkered in
    Posts
    8,542
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    3462

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    maybe i misread that....

    i thought he called her out on

    Quote Originally Posted by tropic of cancer View Post
    tomoreow I will go to zuh Mall',
    taken from his arrogant, transliteration of her accent...demeaning not only what she said, but throwing in her accent as if to reduce its accuracy and boost his status of Naaaaaaaative Speeeeeaker

    "Tomorrow I will go to the mall."

    ...i cant imagine any EFL teacher marking that as incorrect in ANY context. especially in a camp. WAY over the top.

  8. #8
    User. Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara has a reputation beyond repute Lizara's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    2,250
    Blog Entries
    5
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    999

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    ^I don't think we really ought to be speculating on his character based on one post... anyway, it's sort of beside the point, isn't it?

    Personally, I'd teach the way I say it, but I don't correct the students if they've learned "will" from another teacher and are using it. There's really no need to bother them with the nuances of will vs. be going to at that level. It sounds like the exercise is mostly about having them practice using the correct verb tenses, which, IMO, is far more important.

  9. #9
    fending 'em off stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum has a reputation beyond repute stfranalum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    hunkered in
    Posts
    8,542
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    3462

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    speculating on what? i just read his OP. didnt misquote him either. seemed arrogant and insecure to mock his colleagues accent. the point of the grammar is related to that in the sense that he nitpicks her accent and nitpicks her lesson. same same.


    zis iz zah veeh ve duu zings. <-- seems like a pretty arrogant way to demean a colleague who was just offering an example. seemed like a reasonable activity. "lets make an argument about it"



    .....see his posts about getting mad at his students:

    http://www.ajarnforum.net/vb/the-cla...classroom.html (Dealing with anger in the classroom)

    Quote Originally Posted by tropic of cancer View Post
    I go ape with my kids all the time, they're used to it. I feel bad if it's the younger ones
    pattern? or speculation?

  10. #10
    reinstate john terry LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    rayong
    Posts
    7,116
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    4383

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    liz, sorry but you're starting to sound like a headmistress

    Quote Originally Posted by Lizara View Post
    I don't think we really ought to be speculating on his character based on one post...
    get thee back to acronym addicts and let the boys play

  11. #11
    doing a behavioral study jonny danger has disabled reputation jonny danger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    13,641
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    5910

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    'you're wrong to teach the use of will in the sense you mention
    IMO she's wrong to teach grammar in a Summer camp. How about treasure hunt? How about a talent show? Songs?
    Home remedies:
    1. AVOID ARGUMENTS WITH THE FEMALES ABOUT LIFTING THE TOILET SEAT BY USING THE SINK.
    2. IF YOU CAN'T FIX IT WITH A HAMMER, YOU'VE GOT AN ELECTRICAL PROBLEM.
    3. FOR HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE SUFFERERS ~ SIMPLY CUT YOURSELF AND BLEED FOR A FEW MINUTES, THUS REDUCING THE PRESSURE ON YOUR VEINS. REMEMBER TO USE A TIMER.


  12. #12
    Pretty Like Girl WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake has a reputation beyond repute WilliamBlake's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Somewhere hot and wet
    Posts
    14,920
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    6952

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    You're ALL wrong. The accepted non-native speaker expression is: "Tomorrow I go to shopping." Perfectly understandable, and translates easily from the Thai with the use of any Talking Dict.

    Don't go getting your knickers in a twist over such trifles, there's a whole language they have to learn before they can 'hear' the differences you are waffling on about. Mai bpen rai...
    Look at them yo-yos
    That's the way ya TEFL
    You play the hang-man in a sweet EP
    No, that ain't workin'
    That's the way ya TEFL
    Get your Thai baht for nothin' and your giks for free...

  13. #13
    Established User Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster has a reputation beyond repute Grammar Monster's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Bangkok
    Posts
    224
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    46

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    Is the problem not pronunciation rather than grammar?

    If we say 'I will go somewhere tomorrow' and stress 'will' it is rather emphatic, but if we don't stress will, and contract it, so that it sounds like: 'I'll go somewhere tomorrow', it seems perfectly fine to me.
    __________________

    In the sentence "It's one of those things that happen", the antecedent of that which is the subject is not one and so the primacy of one doesn't dictate using the verb 'happens'. Is that explanation correct?

    If you know the answer to the question above, apply now for a job at:


    To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

  14. #14
    Rebellous member Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper has a reputation beyond repute Topper's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    2,852
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    1188

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    Quote Originally Posted by Lizara View Post
    ^I don't think we really ought to be speculating on his character based on one post... anyway, it's sort of beside the point, isn't it?
    Quote Originally Posted by stfranalum View Post
    speculating on what? i just read his OP. didnt misquote him either. seemed arrogant and insecure to mock his colleagues accent. the point of the grammar is related to that in the sense that he nitpicks her accent and nitpicks her lesson. same same.
    Thought there was a mods lounge for these kind of discussions, rather than arguing with each other publicly.

    Let's face it. When someone posts a topic like "Am I being pedantic here? ", about 90% of the time the answer is yes.

    Just my opinion though.

    To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
    Originally Posted by LDMA
    If you have a problem with this stay on SZS.

  15. #15
    reinstate john terry LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket has a reputation beyond repute LoveBucket's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    rayong
    Posts
    7,116
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    4383

    Re: Am I being pedantic here?

    Quote Originally Posted by WilliamBlake View Post
    The accepted non-native speaker expression is: "Tomorrow I go to shopping." Perfectly understandable, and translates easily from the Thai with the use of any Talking Dict.
    i know you are just messing billy boy, but this just about sums it up

    if i can get this out of them, i go home happy

+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

     

Similar Threads

  1. Elephant kills bus!
    By Welshman in forum International News
    Replies: 17
    Last Post: 28th September 2008, 12:00
  2. WWIII Expanding - USrael to Attack Iran Next?
    By Kerux in forum The Soap Box
    Replies: 496
    Last Post: 12th January 2008, 06:22
  3. How pedantic or picky are you?
    By PeaceBlondie in forum Practicalities Of Living In Thailand
    Replies: 36
    Last Post: 26th May 2005, 08:34
  4. What's your morning routine? Are you pedantic, or frantic?
    By Anonymous in forum The Virtual Pub
    Replies: 31
    Last Post: 7th September 2004, 13:23

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts